Property Taxes Explained (and How to Appeal Yours)
Property tax is assessment times rate, and homeowners can influence one of the two. Here is how assessment appeals actually work.
Fact-checked and reviewed for financial accuracy by Priya Kannan, CFP®. Read our content review process.
Your bill is the assessed value multiplied by the tax rate, minus any exemptions. Local governments set the rate; the assessor sets the value. You cannot argue about the rate, but you can argue about the value.
Assessment is not market value
Many jurisdictions assess at a fraction of market value, use a multi-year reassessment cycle, or cap annual increases for owner-occupants. This means your assessed value may look nothing like what your home would sell for, and comparing the two directly is usually a mistake.
Exemptions worth checking
- Homestead exemption for owner-occupied primary residences — the most common and often the largest
- Senior, veteran, and disability exemptions, which vary widely by state
- Assessment caps limiting annual increases for qualifying owners
- Agricultural, conservation, or historic designations where applicable
Appealing an assessment
Appeals succeed when you show the assessor's information is wrong or the value is out of line with comparable properties. They fail when the argument is that the tax is too high.
- Get your property record card from the assessor's office and check the facts: square footage, bedroom and bath count, lot size, basement finish, garage. Factual errors are the easiest wins.
- Pull comparable assessments for similar nearby homes. Most jurisdictions publish these. If similar homes are assessed lower, that is your case.
- Document condition issues with photographs and contractor estimates — a failing roof or foundation problem is relevant to value.
- File within the deadline, which is often short and strictly enforced, typically 30 to 60 days after notices go out.
- Present concisely: the record error or the comparable data, then the value you believe is correct.
What it is worth
A successful appeal that lowers assessed value by $30,000 in a jurisdiction with a 1.4 percent effective rate saves about $420 a year, and often persists until the next reassessment. Many appeals require only a form and an hour of research.
Do not confuse the tax bill with escrow
A successful appeal lowers your tax bill; your monthly escrow payment only adjusts at the next escrow analysis, or sooner if you request one. Contact your servicer with documentation rather than waiting.
Frequently asked questions
Will my property taxes go up when I buy?
In many jurisdictions yes, because the assessment resets near the purchase price and the seller's exemptions end. Ask the assessor what the bill will look like after transfer rather than relying on the current bill.
Is hiring a property tax consultant worth it?
They typically work on contingency, taking a share of the first year's savings. For simple residential appeals, most homeowners can do it themselves.
Are property taxes deductible?
State and local taxes, including property tax, may be deductible subject to federal limits and only if you itemize. Consult a tax professional.
Editorial note. This article is educational and is not tax or legal advice. Property tax rules, assessment practices, and deduction eligibility vary by jurisdiction and change over time. Consult a qualified tax professional about your circumstances.
